What happens when a traumatic memory is reprocessed?EMDR — Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing — is now one of the most extensively studied psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
More than thirty randomised trials have assessed its effectiveness, and numerous international guidelines include it among recommended treatments for PTSD.
One question remains particularly interesting:
what happens to traumatic memory during EMDR?Remembering without being completely in the pastDuring a central part of EMDR, the person connects with elements of a distressing memory while simultaneously keeping part of their attention in the present.
For example, they may follow a side-to-side movement offered by the therapist with their eyes.
This creates a distinctive situation:
the memory is active, but it is not the only thing the brain is doing.The person remembers while also looking, directing attention, sensing their body and remaining connected with what is happening in the present.
This “dual focus” is one of EMDR's most characteristic features.
Eye movements produce a measurable effectFor a long time, researchers debated whether eye movements were truly important or merely an accessory element.
A meta-analysis comparing EMDR with and without eye movements found a significant additional effect of the eye-movement component. In experimental studies, the effect was particularly evident for
memory vividness.
A subsequent meta-analysis of 53 laboratory studies showed that performing a second task while recalling an emotional memory tends to reduce both its vividness and emotional intensity.
One of the most studied models explains this through
working memory.
Recalling a complex image requires cognitive resources. If the brain must perform another task at the same time, the representation may become less vivid and less emotionally intense.
This is an important mechanism, but probably
not the whole story of EMDR.
While the memory is present, the alarm response may also changeSome experimental studies broaden this picture.
In 2018, two neuroimaging experiments showed that goal-directed eye movements activated frontoparietal systems while producing a temporary reduction in amygdala activity.
When this manipulation was combined with memory reactivation in an extinction paradigm, the subsequent return of fear was also reduced.
This suggests an interesting possibility:
a fear memory can remain accessible while the state of the system processing it changes at the same time.These experiments do not reproduce a complete EMDR session. They do show that an attentional task during recall can interact with fear circuits and subsequent safety learning. The effect was not necessarily specific to eye movements: another demanding working-memory task also reduced amygdala activity.
A clue from basic researchA study published in
Nature in 2019 investigated bilateral visual stimulation in an animal model.
In mice, pairing alternating visual stimulation with fear extinction produced a more persistent reduction in the fear response. Researchers identified a circuit involving the superior colliculus, mediodorsal thalamus and amygdala.
An animal model does not, of course, directly demonstrate how EMDR works in humans.
It does offer an important proof of principle:
bilateral sensory stimulation can interact with circuits that regulate the maintenance or reduction of fear responses.
EMDR and exposure: similarities and differencesEMDR and exposure therapies share something fundamental:
the memory or feared experience must be possible to encounter.Avoidance makes it difficult to change learning if a person never comes back into contact with what they fear.
However, EMDR is not simply the same as prolonged exposure.
Contact with the memory takes place through brief sets, a dual past–present focus and observation of the spontaneous associations that emerge.
One possible contemporary interpretation is therefore to consider EMDR as a process in which several elements may work together:
memory reactivation + dual task + changes in vividness + regulation of the alarm response + new learning.An fMRI study in patients with PTSD also observed improved extinction learning after EMDR, accompanied by functional changes in the amygdala, hippocampus, insula and frontal regions.
This does not prove that “EMDR = extinction”. Rather, it indicates that
fear extinction and safety learning may be components of a broader therapeutic process.
The memory does not necessarily have to disappearA processed memory remains part of one's history.
What may change is the way it is recalled.
Initially, it may feel like
“it is happening again”, immediately activating the body, attention and the impulse to defend oneself.
Later, it may increasingly be experienced as
“this happened”.
The difference is not only about what we know cognitively. It concerns how
memory, the body and the alarm response are organised in the present.
From trauma to the possibility of respondingFrom this perspective, change does not simply mean erasing a negative memory.
It means being able to come into contact with that memory without necessarily being compelled to make the same response.
I remember → I feel → I remain in the present → I notice what changes → I learn → I can respond differently.This makes EMDR particularly interesting in the relationship between traumatic memory and agency.
Not because the neuroscience of EMDR directly demonstrates a model of agency, but because it shows how
an experience previously associated with a very rigid response can be processed again under different conditions.
Key scientific referencesLee C.W., Cuijpers P. (2013). A meta-analysis of the contribution of eye movements in processing emotional memories. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 44, 231–239.de Voogd L.D. et al. (2018). Eye-Movement Intervention Enhances Extinction via Amygdala Deactivation. Journal of Neuroscience, 38, 8694–8706.Baek J. et al. (2019). Neural circuits underlying a psychotherapeutic regimen for fear disorders. Nature, 566, 339–343.Rousseau P.F. et al. (2019). Fear extinction learning improvement in PTSD after EMDR therapy: an fMRI study. European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 10, 1568132.Mertens G., Lund M., Engelhard I.M. (2021). The effectiveness of dual-task interventions for modulating emotional memories in the laboratory: A meta-analysis. Acta Psychologica, 220, 103424.de Jongh A., de Roos C., El-Leithy S. (2024). State of the science: Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 37, 205–216.An initial consultationRequest an appointment →Thomas Borsato, PhD · Psychologist and psychotherapist
Order of Psychologists of Lombardy, no. 11270
Further readingMeditation and neuroscienceEMDR and neuroscienceConditioning, fear and safetyHomeItaliano ·
Français ·
English